Saudi patient wants dentist tooth extracted

Home Forums Medicolegal & other legal Issues Saudi patient wants dentist tooth extracted

Welcome Dear Guest

To create a new topic please register on the forums. For help contact : discussdentistry@hotmail.com

Currently, there are 0 users and 1 guest visiting this topic.
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #11050
    Anonymous
    Online
    Topics: 0
    Replies: 1150
    Has thanked: 0 times
    Been thanked: 1 time

     

    Saudi dentist faces “tooth for tooth” ordeal

    Patient asks court to order extraction of dentist’s tooth for error

    What would you do if you visit a dentist and had the wrong tooth removed. The most likely decision is that you will sue the doctor.

    But that was not the case with a Saudi patient who wants to see one of the dentist’s teeth extracted on the basis of “tooth for tooth.”

    Imad Al Zahrani said he had suffered from excruciating pains since he had visited the dentist in the central town of Onaiza.

    He said the dentist made a mistake when he extracted the wrong tooth, causing severe inflammation in the gum for several weeks.

    Zahrani told the Arabic language daily Ajel that he had tried to report the dentist to medical authorities and to his clinic management but they did not take action.

    “I went to court and filed a case asking for the enforcement of the ‘tooth for tooth’ rule…I want the court to order one of the dentist’s teeth removed,” he said.

    The paper did not say whether the court had started hearing the case but quoted an Islamic scholar as saying Zahrani’s request is not permissible in Islam.

    “Zahrani has the legal right to demand damages but he can not ask for the extraction of the dentist’s tooth because what the dentist had done was not deliberate,” said Sheikh Yousuf al Aqel, a professor at the Sharia and Islamic Studies college in the central province of Qasseem.

    #16161
    Anonymous

     an eye for an eye , a tooth for a tooth.

    I am also reminded of what Mahatma Gandhi said : an eye for a eye makes the whole world blind.

    So extrapolating it here a tooth for a tooth makes the whole world edentulous

     

    #16162
    DrAnil
    Offline
    Registered On: 12/11/2011
    Topics: 147
    Replies: 101
    Has thanked: 0 times
    Been thanked: 0 times

     Well said Sir..

    #16167
    Drsumitra
    Offline
    Registered On: 06/10/2011
    Topics: 238
    Replies: 542
    Has thanked: 0 times
    Been thanked: 0 times

     it si essential that we browse through patients charts before initiating treatment

    #16411
    drmithila
    Offline
    Registered On: 14/05/2011
    Topics: 242
    Replies: 579
    Has thanked: 0 times
    Been thanked: 0 times

    Maimuna , a native of Malappuram who suffered from a toothache had a worst day in her life at the Government Dental College Hospital on Saturday. The doctor at the Government Dental College extracted the wrong tooth. Instead of extracting the molar tooth, the dentists extracted the three teeth in the front row.

    According to Maimuna, she went to the Government Dental College last month and after preliminary check-up the doctor had asked her to come to the hospital on Saturday to extract the tooth. Maimuna said that she had informed the doctor to extract the molar tooth prior to the administration of anaesthesia but the doctor extracted the wrong teeth telling that they are conducting the procedure on the basis of prescription in her hand. Maimuna came to know about the removal of teeth only after the completion of extraction. Maimuna has been admitted to the Kozhikode Medical College Hospital.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.